LIKE
the plague of olden days, the contagion is spreading from one
country to the other and is now threatening to infect the very
lungs of Europe, France and Germany. First it was Greece and
Ireland, then Portugal, Italy and Spain, practically in that
order. Now France and Belgium are on the verge of being
downgraded. And the option of ten-year German Bunds last month
shifted only US$ 4.8 billion out of US$ 8 billion worth on
offer.The collapse of the Euro zone
is almost a certainty now unless the German Chancellor Angela
Merkel and the European Central Bank can pull some miracle at
the last minute and try to square a circle. There are signs,
however, that the market is already preparing for the worst and
there are also signs of what such an eventuality could entail.
Industrial orders in the Euro zone fell by 6.4% in September,
the steepest since December, 2008. The index of perceptions of
purchase managers has been reading 47.2, well below the
threshold mark of 50. The European Commission index of consumer
confidence fell again in November for the fifth time in a row.
All these are indicators of a creeping recession.
The situation is getting serious by the
day and a single spark could ignite the entire edifice. The
spark could come in the form of a bank failure leading to a run
on the deposits of other banks or an imminent disorderly default
by Greece or even Italy or a revolt against the austerity
measures being enforced as conditionalities for bail-out
packages. Or France could lose its AAA rating which could
trigger a run on banks across Europe.
The results of the elections in Greece in
February reflecting public anger against austerity measures
coming in as part of the bail-out plan could make Greece leave
the Euro zone and reinvent its own currency. The trend could
then be followed by one peripheral economy after the other. That
could enable these countries to write down the value of their
public and private debts and cut wages and prices relative to
those prevailing in the Euro zone and, in the process, improving
their competitiveness. The countries left in the Euro zone would
then be put at a competitive disadvantage to the new cheaper
currencies just across their borders. That would mean the
erstwhile members of the Euro zone imposing capital controls and
possibly retreating towards autarky by raising retaliatory
tariffs. The death of the Euro zone would naturally lead to the
death of the European single market and the concept of the
European Union itself.
A single currency without a political or
at least a fiscal union was never a bright idea even to start
with. A currency is not just a piece of paper. It acquires
consumer and investor backing only because of the executive and
the legislative force of the sovereign government issuing that
currency. When the sovereignty backing the currency is itself
divided, its different constituents are motivated to behave in
rather irresponsible ways for short term gain vis-à-vis the
other constituents of the grouping. And, when the sovereign
defaults, the investors and the consumers cannot be blamed for
panicking, bringing the entire edifice down. And that is exactly
what has happened in the case of Europe.
The situation can still be salvaged even
at this late stage if the European leaders see reason even at
this at late stage. This month, the European Commission
President, Jose Manuel Barroso came up with two proposals. One
was an agreement on stronger monitoring of national budgets by
Brussels, including the right to recommend changes before they
were submitted to national parliaments and a fierce oversight of
countries in severe difficulties. The second proposal was for
mutualisation of debt by floating common Euro bonds backed by
Euro zone as a whole and by the European Central Bank.
The proposal fiscal union is being
seriously discussed at political levels. Britain has rejected it
outright saying it can not countenance any compromise with its
sovereignty. Sweden is not likely to agree. Some countries have
sought time for internal consultations. But most have reacted
favourably. There is however no movement yet on common euro
bonds or joint liability for the sovereign debts. However, even
steps towards a fiscal union could inspire confidence in the
markets and eventually lead towards some solution to the ongoing
crisis. These are tough times for Europe, though.
· |